CLIENT ALERT: New York Court Invalidates Consensual Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure and Requires Judicial Foreclosure
A commercial real estate foreclosure in New York can take years, even when uncontested. Real estate lenders have employed various strategies to limit costs and delays and create a faster path to title following a default. One such strategy is for the lender to hold a deed in lieu of foreclosure (“DIL”), sometimes called a “deed in the box” or “deed in the drawer,” that the lender may record following a default without resorting to the foreclosure process. In the recent case of Shanghai Commercial Bank Ltd. v. New Tent, LLC et al, No. 850240/2024 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Cnty., June 13, 2026), the court held that a bargained for DIL received by the lender under a forbearance agreement was to be treated as a mortgage and could not be recorded to convey title to the lender or a third party thus forcing the lender to commence a foreclosure sale.
Facts and Ruling
The lenders in Shanghai Commercial made loans secured by a mortgage on commercial property in Manhattan. After the borrower defaulted, the parties entered into a customary forbearance agreement under which the borrower acknowledged the defaults and sought time to cure or refinance, while the lenders agreed not to pursue remedies during the forbearance period. In exchange for the forbearance, the borrowers executed a DIL conveying the property to the lenders if the loans were not repaid by the end of the forbearance period. The forbearance agreement provided that the conveyance of the DIL was “not intended as a mortgage . . . or security instrument of any kind.”
When the loan remained unpaid, however, rather than abide by its agreement to allow the DIL to be recorded, the borrowers contested the lenders’ attempt to record the deed.
In its decision, the court observed even though the forbearance agreement expressly provided that the DIL was “not intended as a mortgage”, New York Real Property Law § 320, provides that a deed that “appears to be intended only as a security in the nature of a mortgage, although an absolute conveyance in terms, must be considered a mortgage.”
Once the deed was treated as a mortgage, the court relied on longstanding precedent holding that a borrower’s “right of redemption” cannot be waived, even when the borrower has expressly agreed to waive it. The DIL therefore could not be recorded, and the lenders were required to proceed through judicial foreclosure. The lenders have appealed, and the appeal remains pending.
Implications for Borrowers and Lenders
The ruling was a significant victory for the borrower, providing substantially more time to pursue a resolution of the loan. It may, however, have consequences—some unintended—for borrowers. Lenders may become less willing to extend credit to certain borrowers or to enter into forbearance agreements after defaults arise. The decision may also prompt real estate lenders to seek alternative forms of security such as personal guarantees; liens on personal or third-party assets; pledged equity; confessions of judgment; amendments to non-recourse carve-out guarantees that are triggered if a DIL is challenged; and similar protections. Some of these alternatives may be more burdensome and costly for borrowers than a DIL.
If you would like to discuss the tools available to both borrowers and lenders, Olshan’s Distressed Real Estate Group develops strategies to help clients best position themselves for success.
This publication is issued by Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising.
Copyright © 2026 Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP. All Rights Reserved.
Attorneys
CLIENT ALERT: New York Court Invalidates Consensual Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure and Requires Judicial Foreclosure
Media Contact
Mizi Mehaj
Director of Marketing
mmehaj@olshanlaw.com
212.451.2319
Public Relations Contact
Promova, LLC
info@getpromova.com
(407) 603-1444
www.getpromova.com
