Popular Topics
All Topics
- 5 Pointz
- Advertising
- Advertising Law
- affordable housing
- AirBNB Lawsuit
- alienation restraints
- ALTA
- ALTA ACSM Standards
- Annual reports
- Assemblages
- Bloomberg BNA
- borrower
- Breach
- Broker-LawyerRelationship
- Broker’s license
- Building Loan Soft Costs
- CARES Act
- Certified B corporation
- checklist
- Climate Change
- Commercial Condo
- Commercial Lease
- Commercial Real Estate
- Commercial Tenant Harassment Law
- Condo Developers
- condominium
- condos
- Contract
- Contractual disputes
- cooperatives
- coops
- Copyright, Trademark and Other Intellectual Property
- Corporate Law
- Corporate social responsibility
- Court Decisions
- COVID-19
- Crowdfunding
- Crowdfunding Rules
- CSR
- Delaware
- Delaware corporate law
- Delaware Good Faith
- Delaware Law
- Delaware LLC
- Disclosure and Reporting
- distressed real estate
- Dodd-Frank Act
- environment, social and governance
- ESG
- Estoppel
- event of default
- FinCEN
- Force Majeure
- foreclosure
- Fraud
- gross negligence
- ground leases
- Inequitable Conduct
- infrastructure
- Insurance Company
- Intellectual Property
- Internal Revenue Code
- internet
- ISLA
- Jennifer Plan
- Job Act Rules
- Joint Venture Agreements
- Landlord
- Law
- Laws
- leasehold condominiums
- lender
- Limited Liability
- Limited Partnerships
- Litigation
- LLC
- LLC Agreement
- LLC Agreement Questions
- LLC Checklist
- LLC Mergers
- LLC taxation
- Loan Agreements
- loan restructurings
- MAE
- Mom and Pop Tenants
- Mortgage Subordination
- mortgages
- Multi-Owner
- New York
- New York Attorney General
- New York City Council
- New York City Surveys
- New York Real Estate Journal
- Non-profit Organization
- NY Attorney General
- NY LLC
- NY Real Estate in 2016
- NY Real Estate in 2018
- NYREJ
- NYS Land Surveyors Association
- NYS Lien Law
- Offering Plan
- online database listing
- opportunity zones
- Ordinary Course Covenant
- Passive Investors
- Public benefit corporation
- Public M&A
- Public Policy
- Purchase Contracts
- Q&A
- quality control
- Real Estate
- Real Estate Development Company
- Real Estate Financing Bureau
- Real Estate Litigation
- Real Estate LLC Agreements
- real estate restructuring negotiations
- Real Estate Taxes
- Real Property Tax (RPT)
- Real-estate-advertising
- retail lease
- Rights of First Refusal
- ROFRs
- rural areas
- Sales
- Sales Tax
- section 1031 exchanges
- Securities & Exchange Commission
- Sellers
- shelter in place
- Sole Discretion
- Specific Disclaimers
- Tax
- tax escalation clause enforcement
- tenancies in common
- TRIA
- VARA
- Visual Artists Rights Act
- Visual Examinations
- “High Volatility” (HVCRE) loans
Recent Posts
- NYREJ Publishes a Review of 2022 by Thomas Kearns
- Update on Using Delaware LLC's vs. NY LLC's
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Commercial Leasehold Condominium Basics
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Alienation Restraints
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Recent Hardship Filings by Landmarked Church
- NYREJ Publishes Article on Data Center Space Leasing by Nina Roket and Jessica Stanton
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Seasonal Rental Concerns
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on the Top 2021 Legal Developments Affecting NY's CRE Industry
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Estoppel Certificates
- NYREJ Publishes Article on the Perceived Inevitability of Collapsing Multi-Owner Properties
Archives
- January 2023
- November 2022
- August 2022
- May 2022
- April 2022
- February 2022
- November 2021
- August 2021
- June 2021
- March 2021
Contact Us
Thomas D. Kearns
tkearns@olshanlaw.com
@TDKearns
212.451.2273
Distressed Real Estate Loan Restructurings in the COVID (and Post COVID) Environment
The COVID‑19 pandemic has caused a “once in 100 years” crisis in many sectors of commercial real estate. Hotels, convention centers, restaurants, theaters, health clubs, and even office buildings around the nation were forced to close or severely limit capacity at times during the pandemic.
Many lenders and landlords have given extensions to debtors and tenants to make payments and offered forbearance agreements (if not formally, then informally). However, as weeks turned into months, often by necessity, enforcement actions were commenced. While some states instituted moratoriums on evictions, those moratoriums often do not apply to lawsuits to collect rent or even terminate a lease. In the lender/borrower context, moratoriums on foreclosures often do not preclude a mezzanine lender’s UCC foreclosure sale, and foreclosures based on “pre-COVID” defaults were often not halted.
In this client alert, we address some key drivers in real estate restructuring negotiations that may impact leverage and negotiating dynamics. Both borrowers and lenders should be mindful of contractual dynamics at play when negotiating a real estate loan restructuring.
“Bad Boy” Guarantees
“Credit rated” securitized CMBS and similar loans are typically non-recourse, meaning the lender can only look to their collateral. However, non-recourse loans often require the sponsor to execute a “non-recourse carve out” or “bad boy” personal guaranty. These carve out guarantees are triggered upon delineated events, such as the filing of bankruptcy proceedings, fraud, waste, or other acts.
In any restructuring, borrowers, sponsors, and lenders alike should carefully review all triggering events. While it is sometimes clear whether a fact pattern will trigger “bad boy” liability, many are not, and some are prime for litigation. Over the years, the list of non-recourse carve outs has grown, including some that have not been tested in court. For example, some carve out events include even raising a defense to a foreclosure lawsuit. Could it be that raising a COVID‑19 defense triggers the guaranty?
Guarantees and Deed-In-Lieu Exposure
Both completion and carry guarantees are common in many commercial real estate deals, especially construction loans. Carry guarantees require the payment of debt service, taxes, and related operational and maintenance costs but typically not the principal of the loan itself. In addition to sponsors providing them to lenders, mezzanine lenders are sometimes required to provide these guarantees to senior lenders, typically when the borrower tenders the pledged interests to the mezzanine lender.
Some lenders are unwilling to foreclose in the depths of the pandemic and borrowers are using lender unwillingness to “take the keys” as useful levers in restructuring discussions, particularly against “underwater” mezzanine lenders.
For borrowers, it is important to know if the mezzanine lender has carry guaranty exposure, as well as what rights exist (or don’t) in the inter-creditor agreement (“ICA”) among the lender groups.
Inter-Creditor Agreements: Inter-Lender Dynamics
ICAs define the relative rights between senior and junior lender. In any restructuring, it is vitally important to understand the rights and remedies of the respective lenders in the ICA. Below are some of the more important provisions in ICAs that often impact restructuring discussions.
Rights to Cure: As mentioned above, an ICA will typically grant the mezzanine or second lien lender rights to cure defaults to preserve the value of its position in the capital structure (typically when the junior lender still believes there is an equity cushion on its junior lien position). By curing and advancing to the senior lender, the mezzanine lender avoids default rate interest, penalties, and possible enforcement actions.
Parties should review the ICA to determine how long the cure right “window” is open. The mezzanine lender should fully understand not only the value of the underlying collateral prior to exercising the cure right, but also the full extent of borrower defaults and what the true cost of curing these defaults are prior to exercising the cure right.
Purchase Options: In addition to the cure right, ICAs typically grant the junior lender the right to purchase the senior mortgage upon a borrower default. Given the possible fast pace of enforcement actions, junior lenders should quickly assess the situation and begin discussions with the senior lender and, if needed, the borrower about a possible restructuring scenario.
Lenders facing this option will need to consider that it is not only agreeing to purchase the senior loan—but also possibly becoming obligated to fund ongoing taxes, maintenance, and other costs for struggling properties.
The borrower should also understand these rights, as well as the relative strength of the mezzanine lender (who may not have the financial ability or contractual right to acquire the senior loan) as these dynamics often become strategic levers in a post-default situation.
Sponsor/Related Party Loan Purchase: ICAs generally restrict a lender from selling its loan to the borrower or affiliates. These provisions often hamper many avenues to a sponsor-led workout and may, therefore, require amendment to allow for certain restructuring transactions, including possible sponsor-led discounted pay offs. As part of forbearance or loan modification negotiations, sponsors may wish to consider seeking amendment of these provisions to allow for the acquisition of the mortgage loan and a discounted pay off.
When we exit the pandemic, with the hope of vaccines and resumption of “life as normal,” the need for commercial real estate loan restructurings and rescue financings will be essential for all parties.