Popular Topics
All Topics
- 5 Pointz
- Advertising
- Advertising Law
- affordable housing
- AirBNB Lawsuit
- ALTA
- ALTA ACSM Standards
- Assemblages
- Bloomberg BNA
- Breach
- Broker-LawyerRelationship
- Broker’s license
- Building Loan Soft Costs
- Certified B corporation
- checklist
- Climate Change
- Commercial Condo
- Commercial Tenant Harassment Law
- commerical real estate
- Condo Developers
- condominium
- condos
- Contract
- Copyright, Trademark and Other Intellectual Property
- Corporate Law
- Corporate social responsibility
- Court Decisions
- COVID-19
- Crowdfunding
- Crowdfunding Rules
- CSR
- Delaware corporate law
- Delaware Good Faith
- Delaware Law
- Dodd-Frank Act
- environment, social and governance
- ESG
- event of default
- FinCEN
- foreclosure
- Fraud
- gross negligence
- ground leases
- Inequitable Conduct
- infrastructure
- Insurance Company
- Intellectual Property
- Internal Revenue Code
- internet
- ISLA
- Jennifer Plan
- Job Act Rules
- Joint Venture Agreements
- leasehold condominiums
- Limited Liability
- Limited Partnerships
- LLC
- LLC Agreement
- LLC Agreement Questions
- LLC Checklist
- LLC Mergers
- LLC taxation
- Loan Agreements
- MAE
- Mom and Pop Tenants
- Mortgage Subordination
- mortgages
- New York
- New York Attorney General
- New York City Council
- New York City Surveys
- New York Real Estate Journal
- Non-profit Organization
- NY Attorney General
- NY Real Estate in 2016
- NY Real Estate in 2018
- NYREJ
- NYS Land Surveyors Association
- NYS Lien Law
- Offering Plan
- online database listing
- opportunity zones
- Ordinary Course Covenant
- Passive Investors
- Public benefit corporation
- Public M&A
- Public Policy
- Purchase Contracts
- quality control
- Real Estate
- Real Estate Development Company
- Real Estate Financing Bureau
- Real Estate Litigation
- Real Estate LLC Agreements
- Real Estate Taxes
- Real Property Tax (RPT)
- Real-estate-advertising
- retail lease
- Rights of First Refusal
- ROFRs
- rural areas
- Sales
- Sales Tax
- section 1031 exchanges
- Securities & Exchange Commission
- Sellers
- Sole Discretion
- Specific Disclaimers
- Tax
- tax escalation clause enforcement
- tenancies in common
- TRIA
- VARA
- Visual Artists Rights Act
- Visual Examinations
- “High Volatility” (HVCRE) loans
Recent Posts
- NYREJ Publishes a Review of 2020 by Thomas Kearns
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on the Top 2020 Legal Developments Affecting NY’s CRE Industry
- Delaware Chancery Court Provides Important Guidance on COVID-19’s Impact on a Buyer’s Obligation to Close:
- Infrastructure Needed to Cure Digital Divide in the U.S.
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Foreclosures for Technical Mortgage Defaults
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Hotel Ground Lease Defaults
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Gross Negligence
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Returning to Offices After COVID-19
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Protecting Co-Investors in LLC Agreements
- Acronyms, Abbreviation and Jargon in New York Commercial Real Estate
Archives
- February 2021
- December 2020
- October 2020
- August 2020
- June 2020
- April 2020
- March 2020
- January 2020
- December 2019
- September 2019
Contact Us
Thomas D. Kearns
tkearns@olshanlaw.com
@TDKearns
212.451.2273
What’s Market for Real Estate Joint Venture Partnerships?
The following article was published in the July 19, 2016 issue of the New York Real Estate Journal.
Full article content reprinted with permission below. To view on the New York Real Estate Journal site, please click here.
I’m involved in a dozen or more real estate joint venture agreements (typically LLC agreements) every year. When I look back, I see consistent terms in those agreements despite the wide variety of transactions. For example, I represent both ground up residential condo developers and office building operators but the joint venture terms are usually quite similar. Here are a few basics that I would consider market for joint ventures between an experienced real estate sponsor/operator and an investment fund.
Management
During the recession of 2008 to 2010, there seemed to be a trend of fund investors trying to put themselves in the position of the managing member of the LLC. But that trend, if it was one, now seems to be over. Universally, funds now permit the real estate sponsor to be the managing member of the LLC with certain major decision veto powers reserved to the fund and rights to remove the sponsor for bad acts.
Removal of Managing Member
Over the years I would see occasional removal clauses requested by funds that were performance based, i.e., if condo sales or occupancy rates didn’t hit certain milestones or net operating income fell too low. In those circumstances, the fund could remove the sponsor from its position as managing member of the LLC. The clauses were painful to negotiate and frustrating to both sides and removal based on those clauses seemed rare. I have not seen a performance based removal clause requested in years - funds appear to recognize that market conditions are too hard to predict and, given the interrelationships of the parties and legacy guarantee obligations, too complex to unwind. Removal clauses are now tied to bad acts like fraud, theft and breach with cure periods including a cure period to terminate a rogue employee.
Guarantees
The sponsor typically agrees to furnish a creditworthy entity to sign loan guarantees protecting the lender from fraudulent and other bad acts of the borrower. Since the sponsor is typically the managing member with day-to-day control of the venture, that makes sense. The sponsor is also given the right to control the venture’s decisions which would be covered by the bad act guaranty. In other words, the sponsor is not subject to the fund’s veto over acts to comply with the terms of the loan once the loan and its terms are approved by the fund.
Forced Sale and Rights of First Offer
Funds are typically granted the right to force a sale of the project after some initial stabilization period. But that right is always subject to a right of first offer in favor of the sponsor. Essentially, the fund may send a notice saying it wants to sell but the notice will set forth a value and the sponsor will have the right to buy the property from the venture at that value often with a new loan and a new partner thereby keeping the property under the sponsor’s control.
Affiliated Transactions
All real estate LLC agreements limit transactions either side can cause the venture to engage in with affiliates. Sponsors typically get upfront fund approval of development, management or leasing agreements with its affiliates and funds agree that if they take control of the venture they will not engage in affiliated transactions without sponsor approval or without complying with a market standard.
By standardizing many of these issues, funds and sponsors help the efficiency of the market and reduce legal wrangling and fees.
Thomas Kearns is a partner with Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP’s real estate department, New York, N.Y.