Popular Topics
All Topics
- 5 Pointz
- Advertising
- Advertising Law
- affordable housing
- AirBNB Lawsuit
- ALTA
- ALTA ACSM Standards
- Assemblages
- Bloomberg BNA
- Breach
- Broker-LawyerRelationship
- Broker’s license
- Building Loan Soft Costs
- Certified B corporation
- checklist
- Climate Change
- Commercial Condo
- Commercial Tenant Harassment Law
- commerical real estate
- Condo Developers
- condominium
- condos
- Contract
- Copyright, Trademark and Other Intellectual Property
- Corporate Law
- Corporate social responsibility
- Court Decisions
- COVID-19
- Crowdfunding
- Crowdfunding Rules
- CSR
- Delaware corporate law
- Delaware Good Faith
- Delaware Law
- Dodd-Frank Act
- environment, social and governance
- ESG
- event of default
- FinCEN
- foreclosure
- Fraud
- gross negligence
- ground leases
- Inequitable Conduct
- infrastructure
- Insurance Company
- Intellectual Property
- Internal Revenue Code
- internet
- ISLA
- Jennifer Plan
- Job Act Rules
- Joint Venture Agreements
- leasehold condominiums
- Limited Liability
- Limited Partnerships
- LLC
- LLC Agreement
- LLC Agreement Questions
- LLC Checklist
- LLC Mergers
- LLC taxation
- Loan Agreements
- MAE
- Mom and Pop Tenants
- Mortgage Subordination
- mortgages
- New York
- New York Attorney General
- New York City Council
- New York City Surveys
- New York Real Estate Journal
- Non-profit Organization
- NY Attorney General
- NY Real Estate in 2016
- NY Real Estate in 2018
- NYREJ
- NYS Land Surveyors Association
- NYS Lien Law
- Offering Plan
- online database listing
- opportunity zones
- Ordinary Course Covenant
- Passive Investors
- Public benefit corporation
- Public M&A
- Public Policy
- Purchase Contracts
- quality control
- Real Estate
- Real Estate Development Company
- Real Estate Financing Bureau
- Real Estate Litigation
- Real Estate LLC Agreements
- Real Estate Taxes
- Real Property Tax (RPT)
- Real-estate-advertising
- retail lease
- Rights of First Refusal
- ROFRs
- rural areas
- Sales
- Sales Tax
- section 1031 exchanges
- Securities & Exchange Commission
- Sellers
- Sole Discretion
- Specific Disclaimers
- Tax
- tax escalation clause enforcement
- tenancies in common
- TRIA
- VARA
- Visual Artists Rights Act
- Visual Examinations
- “High Volatility” (HVCRE) loans
Recent Posts
- Delaware Chancery Court Provides Important Guidance on COVID-19’s Impact on a Buyer’s Obligation to Close:
- Infrastructure Needed to Cure Digital Divide in the U.S.
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Foreclosures for Technical Mortgage Defaults
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Hotel Ground Lease Defaults
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Gross Negligence
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Returning to Offices After COVID-19
- Acronyms, Abbreviation and Jargon in New York Commercial Real Estate
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Top Legal Developments of 2019 in NY Real Estate
- NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Mortgage Break-Up Fees
Archives
- December 2020
- October 2020
- August 2020
- June 2020
- April 2020
- March 2020
- January 2020
- December 2019
- September 2019
- July 2019
Contact Us
Thomas D. Kearns
tkearns@olshanlaw.com
@TDKearns
212.451.2273
NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on Protecting Co-Investors in LLC Agreements
New York Real Estate Journal published an article authored by Olshan Real Estate partner Thomas Kearns entitled “LLC Agreement Issues for Co-Investors.”
Limited liability companies or “LLCs” are used to hold the vast majority of U.S. real estate investments. Outside of REITs and other corporate owned real estate, investments of any significant size typically include a large institutional capital partner and a more entrepreneurial operating partner (or, in the language of LLCs, “member”) with each contributing a share of the equity required for the deal. Operating members often offer a portion of their investment to permit small investments to be made by friendly co-investors. Sometimes that invitation is done as a favor, i.e., to reward an investor’s loyalty on other deals or to return a favor granted by the investor, and sometimes because the operating member needs the money in order to meet the requirements of the institutional investor.
When the invitation to a smaller investor arrives it can be accompanied by a “we’re in a hurry” message with the clear implication that the co-investor won’t be able to negotiate the terms of the agreement governing the LLC. So what should such smaller investors and their lawyers look for in the draft LLC agreement? And what should the operating member instruct its lawyer to include in the agreement so that the small investors are comfortable with the terms of the investment? This column mentions a few and assumes the small investor has no or minimal negotiating leverage.
Perhaps the primary issue to review is whether the operating member has disclaimed fiduciary duty. A disclaimer can be made in Delaware LLCs but not New York LLCs since New York does not permit a broad disclaimer. An operating member should think twice before including a broad disclaimer in the proposed Delaware LLC agreement given to investors because of the negative impression it will give small investors. With a fiduciary duty standard, the investor can at least feel that he or she will be treated fairly. Without it, all bets are off.
Next, small investors typically invest because they trust the operating member. If the proposed LLC agreement permits the operating member to transfer all of its interest in the LLC to a third party without the consent of the small investors, the small investors could be stuck with an illiquid investment in an entity managed by a stranger. The easy solution is a “tag-along” clause which lets the small investor sell its interest to the same third party at the same price. While a tag-along clause is a mild drag on the marketability of the operating member’s interest, most agree that it’s only fair to permit the small investor to tag-along on the sale. The clause typically doesn’t apply to transfers by the operating member to affiliates or to partial sales.
Finally, since most small investors are individuals, the right of the small investor to transfer his or her interest for estate planning purposes and on death or disability is key. Failure to include commonly used permitted transfer provisions could lead to a default, a heavily discounted forced sale, or even forfeiture of the interest depending on the terms of the LLC agreement.
In short, small investors should look for, and operating members should consider including in the first draft, a few key protections for the smaller investors to give them comfort that they will be treated fairly.
Thomas Kearns is a partner with Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP’s real estate department, New York, N.Y.